EDGAR ALLAN POE


Comentarios

  1. The fall of the house of Usher:
    We like this story because it's easy to read and understand, furthermore it's very interesting and mysterious. The story is very funny.

    The black cat:
    We don't like this story because it has animal abuse and it's very bloody but it's easy to read too.

    Laura y Nerea.

    ResponderEliminar
  2. The fall of the house's Usher

    This chapter is more interesting that "the black cat", but is more difficult, the best of the chapter is the end, when Usher became mad.
    The Narrator is a person very good because he helps his school friend. Usher's illness is very strange.

    The Black Cat

    This chapter is more boring and easier that the first chapter. The most interesting in the chapter is when the narrator try to kill the cat, but he fails and kill her wife.
    The most boring is when the narrator begin to talk about his pets.

    Rubén Martín Bautista and Francisco Rueda Guerrero
    1º Bach. C

    ResponderEliminar
  3. Desireé Luque Gallego, Dennis Steffanie López Arreaga y Miriam Guirado Salmerón - 1º Bach. C
    -The fall of the house's Usher-
    This story is more difficult than Black cat; although we like this story more. The story has mistery and in the end it makes a big impression on you.
    -Black Cat-
    Black cat is very awful and bored because the protagonist is murderous and crazy because he mistreats his wife and his cat. Although this story is easier than the other story, we don't like it.

    ResponderEliminar
  4. Álvaro y Pedro 1ºC11 de enero de 2010, 1:06

    The Fall Of Usher's House
    We think that this story is really good because we had a good time reading it. The final is very interesting and mysterious. We believe that this story isn't very hard to read.

    The Black Cat
    we think that this story is more interesting that the other novel, the mystery keep until the final. we believe that this story is more easy to read that other story.

    ResponderEliminar
  5. The Fall of Usher's house:

    We think that it's a good story,mysterious and with enough intrigue.We don't like the end because it leaves the end without resolving.

    The Black Cat

    It's a predictable story.It doesn't take so many intrigue as the first tale and doesn't scare.There are parts of the story slightly convincent.

    Miguel Amores & Alejandro Fernández

    ResponderEliminar
  6. *The fall of the house Usher:We didn't like because in the fisrt history there isn't fear. Moreover, it was eassy because before we read in class and it was very confused.

    *The black cat:We like the black cat because it was very interested and it had much mystery. It was easy to understand because the vocabulary was very very simple.

    Houda Chrouh y Laura Caldado Montiel. 1º bach C

    ResponderEliminar
  7. Jose Pablo Martínez Sepúlveda.
    Juan Carlos Bueno Perales.

    Chapter One
    The fall of the Usher's house.

    We thing that this chapter is more difficult to read than the second chapter, because we have to use the diccionary for a lot of words, but it was very interesting because is misterious.
    Although it's over the top, the history is really short.
    In the history, the most interesting is when Usher's sister appear in his bedroom.

    The Black Cat

    This history is a bit short because is more easy to read and we had to search few words in the dictionary. This history is interesting too, although it isn't too logic, because the cat was in the double wall with the dead woman, when he had to stay with his owner.
    The history is too disaagreeable.

    ResponderEliminar
  8. THE BLACK CAT

    We`ve selected this history because it`s the most interesting for us.
    This history is more funny that the other until the moment that the man kill his wife and it begins the nightmare.
    Also, it`s easy to read.
    In spite of it`s a bit devilish, we advise to read it because you don`t know the finish unless you read every history.

    Sara Sancho Garcia
    Carme Escobar Romero
    1ºC

    ResponderEliminar
  9. The Black Cat

    For Start we'll start speaking about the history "The Black Cat"
    We think that the best thing is that in the end of the history the cat is who discovered the murder. The cat discovered him making noises. The thing of the chapter that we didn't like of the history is that the protagonist used to hit to the wife and his cat.

    The fall of the house of usher

    For Start we think that the history of the fall of usher is very interesting because is a very unusual history. In Addition Usher has a strange illness of the senses and it looks very good. We really like when the Usher's sister got up of the coffin. ¡It was very dark !
    On the other hand we didnt like of the history that the protagonist "Usher" was very autistic and he was speaking alone always how if he looks a crazy person.


    Name :
    Adrián Ramírez Chamizo
    Iván González Espinosa

    ResponderEliminar
  10. The black cat.
    We think that it is a very boring story and it isn't frightening. The protagonist's actions don't make sense because he does some strange things and we don't know the reason why, for example when he kills his wife or why he hates his cat. In conclusion, it is easy to read and we haven't had any problem to read it,although we don't like this story very much.

    The fall of the house of Usher.
    We think that this story is more interesting that the other one because is more frightening. It is more intriging and you want to continue reading it to know the story's end. It is more dificult to read that the other story but whe like it more that the other one.

    María Nieves García Arrabal
    Rocío Díaz Ruíz
    Tamara López Merino

    ResponderEliminar
  11. Selma Azzaoui and Mónica Oviedo 1ºC11 de enero de 2010, 1:21

    THE BLACK CAT
    We have chosed this history because we have seemed it more interesting.
    We liked very much because is fantastic, intriguing and also misterious.
    We sorprised when the house burned in flames and the silhouette of cat appared in the wall. This silhouette was of the cat that was looking to Pluto, the pet of the protagonist that he killed it.

    ResponderEliminar
  12. Juan Carlos Bueno Perales
    Jose Pablo Martínez Sepúlveda

    Libro recomendado:
    -El Ejército Negro
    -1984

    ResponderEliminar
  13. cintia sanchez pineda 1ªbach.c11 de enero de 2010, 1:26

    THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER:
    For my the story"the fall of the house of usher" a bit difficult to read,but doesn´t became heavy because has moments of intrigue and suspense.

    THE BLACK CAT:

    the story "the black cat" speaks on a man lover of animals and has a cat,fish,bird...the man because problems gives him for driving and one of the days arrived drank,the cat arrived rang and the man hangs.
    then bought another cat who encloses it between of the cellar.

    ResponderEliminar
  14. the fall of the house of usher:

    It's a great long story. It's a bit schemer. The protagonist is a normal person but his friend, Roderick usher is mad, is crazy. Along this tale, the protagonist fell deep in glomm. Perhaps, i won't know what to do in that situation.

    The black cat:

    it's a shorter tale, but it's more amazing than other. This story is more interesting and thrilling.

    both stories have new vocabulary and some new set phrases.

    Alummno: Luna Martínez Montes y Jonathan Hernández Rodríguez 1º Bach-c

    ResponderEliminar
  15. We've like the story, because is interesting. It's a fantastic story, because it's say a imaginary situation ,A man go to visit a sick friend in a castle, where live with your sister, also is sick,of a strange sickness. When she fall in this sickness, they think she's died. A night of strong rain, they heard a
    We've like the story, because is interesting. It's a fantastic story, because it's say a imaginary situation ,A man go to visit a sick friend in a castle, where live with your sister, also is
    We've like the story, because is a interesting sick,of a strange sickness. When she fall in this sickness, they think she's died. A night of strong rain, they heard a noise and the sister stand up of your coffin,the sister fall on usher, and the house falled.
    The black cat:
    We've like the story, because is interesting, is a intrigant story, the argument of the history is good, because how more you read, more want continues read,in this story the mean character kill his cat. After he find a alike cat. This cats have a white spot. The mean chracter kill at his wife, and the police go to investigate at his house. A miaow have the police open the wall and the cat was on top of head of the died wife.
    Aurelio Ruiz, José Joaquín España 1ºC

    ResponderEliminar
  16. The fall of the house of Usher:

    The fall of the house of Usher is a terrorific and mistery story. It's very interesting. We don't like the end of the story because it's very bad and pessimistic.

    The black cat:

    The black cat begins as a beautiful story, but the end is very bloody. We don't like these stories. We like nice story. We don't like these stories unless they are interesting and exciting.


    The stories are bit difficult.


    Francisco José Jiménez Pozo y Paula García Hernández. 1º Bachillerato A.

    ResponderEliminar
  17. the fall of the house of usher.
    We think that this history is very beautiful, has many moments of intrigue that makes history is very good.
    The protagonist has a strange illness, and he just die

    The black cat.
    The history is about a man who loves animals and alcohol.
    This history is more entertaining than the other, and easy to understand


    Francisco Daniel Bravo Gómez 1ºA
    Rocío Luque Aragón 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  18. the fall of the house of usher.
    We think that this history is very beautiful, has many moments of intrigue that makes history is very good.
    The protagonist has a strange illness, and he just die

    The black cat.
    The history is about a man who loves animals and alcohol.
    This history is more entertaining than the other, and easy to understand

    Francisco Daniel Bravo Gomez
    Rocio Luque Aragon
    1º A

    ResponderEliminar
  19. The Black Cat...

    We like this story because it reflects the way drinking causes a degradation of the moral of the protagonist and drives to madness.

    Jonatan Ortega
    Angel Jimenez

    1º Bach A

    ResponderEliminar
  20. THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER:

    We didn't like this story because it was a bit hard to read and a bit boring. Besides that, it wasn't scary enough.

    Level of difficulty: 8

    THE BLACK CAT:

    We liked this story because it was way more scary and interesting than the previous one. We don't like the people who abuse animals and women, but it's a good story.

    Level of difficulty: 7

    José David Cuenca Torres
    Jesús Manuel León Martín
    1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  21. They are macabre short stories, the writer drives us to his ill mind (caused by opium and his life in prision). It's the best book for heavy emotions.

    Dani Martin 1º A

    ResponderEliminar
  22. The black cat:

    It is a story a bit strange, because if he had so much love for animals. why did he kill the cat? what I can not understand is how the cat was locked inside the wall as well. personally we don't like the text.
    LEVEL OF DIFFICULT:***

    the fall of the house of usher:

    this is another strange history ,this story is more funny.
    is a family that is a bit sick in the head and he was their friend realizes in the end. personally this story attracts the readers much.
    LEVEL OF DIFFICULT:***

    lAURA TELLEZ ARJONA Y VICTOR MANUEL ALBARRACIN LUNA.

    ResponderEliminar
  23. The fall of Usher's house:

    We don't like this story because it has been difficult to understand but we like the story because it's interesting.
    Therefore we think it's interesting because the sister finally doesn't die and they had a strange illness.

    Melisa Campos, Miriam Ordoñez 1ºBach A

    ResponderEliminar
  24. The fall of the house of Usher:
    We haven't liked the story, because we don't understand it
    The level is very difficult.
    The black cat:
    Sonia has liked the story, because she likes horror stories.
    Adrián hasn't liked the story, because he doesn't like horror stories.
    The level is difficult.
    Sonia Vela, Adrián Vergara 1ºA.

    ResponderEliminar
  25. STORYS OF ENGLISH

    The fall of house of usher:

    This story don't like we, because it's boring; we think that the story is very dark and in the story there isn't heroes and we are superheroes.

    The black cat:

    This story like we, because it's interesting; the cat is like a superhero, because it appears in the eyes of other cat so that frighten to its owner.


    CARLOS RODRIGUEZ MARIN, JESUS RUIZ NIETO 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  26. the fall of the house of usher
    we've like it because the history is interesting and intriging. I thing what the boy is fascinating, because have senses sharpned.

    the black cat
    we've like it because the history is very funny and the argument is very mistery. The Story is interesting by the cat seem what have two life.

    Name: Laura Guerrero Montañez and Laura Ortiz Aguilar

    ResponderEliminar
  27. THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER:
    the story``The fall of the house of Usher´´is very entertaining,because the story is about the mistery of house where odd events happen.
    The horrible part is when women are stuck living in the coffi.
    This part very scary!!!
    Name:Natalia Medina Domínguez 1ºA
    THE BLACK CAT:
    the story ``The Black cat´´,tells the life of man who he love animals;but because stars out ot kills.
    He had a black cat very precious,but eventually it was evil and kill him.
    YOU CAN'T MISS THE STORY!
    IS VERY INTRIGUING...
    Name:Ghizlan El ouelkadi Chouh 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  28. Miriam Ordóñez Fernández
    The history of the book the pit and the pendulum me to seemed very entertaining and interesting.
    The murder on the Rue Morgue me to seemed amazing.
    They have a level adapted for us.

    ResponderEliminar
  29. ARINA CRISTINA GINTU 1 BAC A
    I read a history called the mourders and the rue morgue this story is a horror story about a mum and his daughter how a monster kill them and the police of paris sreach him but is very difficult found him but in finally found him ,the monster is a monkey . in my opinion this book is interesantbut very horrory for the young child.

    ResponderEliminar
  30. Luna Palma Paneque 1ºA Bachillerato
    The pit on the Pendum:
    The book is difficult for me, although, he is very interesting and very entertained.

    ResponderEliminar
  31. Juan Jose Restrepo 1a bachiller


    THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER:
    This story has me very entertaining and interesting pair due to go home in many mysteries. give a little bit of fear and recommend this book as.

    ResponderEliminar
  32. The Murders in the Rue Morgue
    I think that this story is more interesting than other stories that we have read.
    The story isn't very difficult,but it has a lot of new words.I like this story because the plot is interesting,and the events are intriguing.
    For me,Edgar Allan Poe is a good writer of horror stories.
    I also like the form to resolve misteries of the protagonist.I think that he is very clever.

    Paula Amores Luque 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  33. I think that the stories are interesting and intriging although they're too fantastic for me. I prefer real stories , however this book has been entertaining.
    Level of difficult: medium

    Marina Trujillo 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  34. The story The Murder on the rue Morgue tell about a murder of two women in their house. Investigating, the police discovered that the assasin is an orang-utang.
    I like this story because is intriguing when we don't know who the assassin is. But when the police discovered it I was very surprise.
    Ornella Volpintesta 1º Bach A.

    ResponderEliminar
  35. The Murders in the Rue Morgue:The level is easy.The book is very insteresting.

    The Pit and the Pendulum:The story is about the torments endured by a prisoner of the Spanish Inquisition. It is a good story.

    Name:Ismael Aguilar Calderón 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar
  36. ARINA CRISTINA GINTU 1 BAC A
    THE PIT AND THE PENDULUM .
    FIRSTLY I WANT SAY THAT THIS STORY IS ALSO A HORROR STORY ABOUT A MAN THAT FALLS IN HAND OF THE INQUISITION AND THE INQUISITION HAVE FOR HE A PROFS OR A TURTERS THAT THEY APLLY HIM AND OUR PERSONAGE WILL BE VERY FRIGHTENED AND HE WILL HAVE A PANIC ATTAC BUT FINALLY THE THINGS WILL BE WELL BECAUSE THE TRIBUNAL INQUISITION WILL FALL IN HAND OF POLICE IN ESPITE OF THE FACT THAT OUR MAN HAS PASSED FOR THREE PROFS AND HE WILL BE HORRORY. IN MY OPINION THIS STORY SHOULDNT READ THE YOUNG CHILD BECAUSE IS VERY FRIGHTENED.

    ResponderEliminar
  37. The Murders in the Rue Morgue
    The story is interesting because the murderer we don't know who the killer is until the end.
    In summary, I think teenegers will like this story because horror is very popular among young people.

    The Pit and the Pendulum
    I think that this is very strange,because the plot is very complicated because you get confused about the time.It goes backwards and forwards.
    In the story,we don't know certainly the time that it pass when he is slept and awake.

    Jennifer Andrea Aguirre 1ºA

    ResponderEliminar

Publicar un comentario

No olvides escribir nombre, apellidos y curso al principio de tu comentario. Elige Perfil Anónimo y después pincha Publicar.